Re: [Feedback] Categorizing Videos and presentations of ELC, ELCE, and Japan Technical Jamboree
Tim Bird
Please find below my feedback on the proposed category list
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message-----Overall - Is each item below intended to be a standalone page, or is the intent that sub-topics will be sections within a top-level page? Some of the sub-topics (e.g. RealTime) really are big enough to have their own top-level page (or even several pages). Maybe this will depend on the number of talks that end up on a page? Here is the proposed category list:I'm not sure what "Status Check" is - can you give an example talk in this category, or describe it more? ** UpstreamingMaybe add "Legal" here? ** LTSILTSI might go better under "distributions"?, but I'm not sure. * [[Buildsystems]]There are lots more: OpenWRT, Embedded Debian, Debos, etc. How would you categorize ELBE, which builds binary distributions from Debian? Would it go on this page? * SchedulerI'm not sure I see scheduler as a top-level page. I'm not sure how many scheduler talks we've had. Power-management scheduling was a big topic for a while (e.g. big.LITTLE), but maybe going back farther there were lots of talks when the O(1) scheduler was introduced. ** Real TimeRealTime is big enough to deserve it's own top-level page. Likely, Scheduler is not big enough to deserve it's own top-level page. In fact, RealTime might deserve two pages: one for PREEMPT_RT and the other for dual-kernel approaches (e.g. Xenomai) ** Interrupt latencyAlso BareBox * Boot TimeI'm not sure what the "Source code" category is here. * File SystemsDoes "IO scheduling" go here? * Flash StorageSecurity divides into multiple categories. There are mandatory access control systems, like SELinux, AppArmor, Smack, Tomoyo. And then there are different aspects of security like: ** Secure Boot ** Cryptography ** Trusted stores (TPM) ** Hardening * UpgradesOK - maybe this should be a standalone page, but it's kind of in the non-technical category of pages. * MultimediaWe need Intel or x86 as well (and maybe mips) * Compilers** LLVM/Clang ** Linkers, LoadersDon't we already have Scheduling above? * Memory ManagementI would put Fuego underneath a sub-category of ** Test Frameworks *** Fuego, KernelCI, Kselftest, I would add: ** Board farms and infrastructure * EmbeddedNot sure what "MPPWG" is. ** Digital STBAdd ftrace here. * DistributionsI thought Tomoyo was a security system, not a distro, but I could be wrong. ** AndroidI'm not sure * MiscellaneousLegal could also go here? * ApplicationsThis category seems to be "Development Tools", not applications. ** SDKI think I'd stick these under "networking", but some are higher-level protocols. ** UPnPI don't think that "Open Source Projects" is a good category for these sub-topics: ** ZephyrWe should probably have a "non-Linux RTOS" page. I think there have been several different talks over the years for non-Linux OSes (NuttX, Zephyr, Free RTOS, etc.) ** BeagleBone BoardWe should have a "Hardware" category for these board-specific talks. These should be under networking ** Stream Processing for IoTI think I'd put "Home Automation" as it's own topic (not under IoT) maybe also add "Embedded Industrial Systems" as a topic? ** X-Ref selected topics/presentations with Networking Category (See above)I'd put Robotics and Drones under verticals. -- Tim |
|